-->
CANUCKS HOCKEY BLOG

Tuesday, January 17, 2006

The NHL on NBC

After awaiting for months to see if NBC can do to the NHL what it did for the NBA a few years ago, I ended up only catching a couple of periods of the Colorado/Philadelphia game from my hotel room. I have to admit, it's not bad.

Personally, I liked that they kept the broadcast simple - good camera angles, clean graphic across the top and no glowing puck. The shift counters were a nice touch but I didn't like that they ended up covering more of the screen. If they moved the graphics higher on the screen, maybe it would be okay. Compared to the few OLN broadcasts I've seen (only the ones they've shown on the NHL Network in Canada), I'd have to give the early edge to NBC.

Let's see if the TV ratings, when they come out, reflect that.

Some of the other hockey bloggers have already weighed in on this first weekend of NHL on NBC action. Here are a sampling of their thoughts.

From James Mirtle:
Even aside from the games, I thought NBC did a great job with the presentation aspects of the game, as everything looked and, for the most part, sounded sharp. How nice was it to hear Hockey Night in Canada castoff Chris Cuthbert calling the Dallas-Boston game? Cuthbert's one of the best hockey play-by-play men in the world, so it's nice to see he was picked up to call games here.

It was a little surreal to see TSN analyst Pierre McGuire crammed between the Detroit/Rangers benches in a little cube of space, and McGuire's interjections into the game crew's conversations were sometimes ill-timed. Three voices is perhaps one too many for a hockey broadcast considering how fast the game moves along, but it's nice to see broadcasters trying to innovate with their game presentation.

It's no Hockey Night in Canada, but what I saw today was certainly better than most of the American broadcasts I see on my NHL Centre Ice package. It's too bad NBC didn't start showing games from the beginning of the season.
From Dubi Silverstein of Blueshirt Bulletin:
The game was NBC's first under their new NHL contract, and though they did better than OLN by keeping things simpler, there were a couple of problems. We watched in HD, and there was one camera angle that was weird -- we're not sure if that camera was not HD, but those shots were grainy and made everyone within them look like they were just embalmed.
From Matt Saler of On The Wings:
I enjoyed the NBC broadcast much more than the OLN versions, though I still prefer FSN. Bill Clement and Ray Ferraro were the studio crew, with Mark Messier joining them in the intermissions. Mike Emrick and John Davidson were in the booth but Pierre McGuire was between the benches and provided insights throughout the game. NBC kept track of the ice time of Brendan Shanahan and Jaromir Jagr, keeping a special clock under the scoreboard whenever either of the two were on the ice. I can't say I paid much attention to it, though.
Abel to Yzerman and Kukla's Corner have more detailed posts on the broadcasts as well.

______________
Comments/Questions: Feel free to post in the comments section or email me at gocanucksgo10 (at) hotmail (dot) com.

Technorati Tags: , ,
posted by J.J. Guerrero, 6:29 AM

2 Comments:

At January 17, 2006 10:53 PM, Blogger BCSportsFanatic said...

Hockey on NBC or any other Major Network is a joke. OLN is so bad, it's not even worth talking about.

NBC picked a pretty crappy time to broadcast NHL games, I mean come on NFL playoffs are on. And the Broncos were playing to boot. Did anyone in Denver even know the Avs were playing let alone care??

ESPN did a fantastic job with the NHL, too bad they get more people to watch rodeo and bowling then NHL and thus dumped the NHL at the last moment.

 
At January 20, 2006 6:55 AM, Blogger J.J. Guerrero said...

They didn't have much of a choice, except perhaps to start airing games at the start of the season or on Christmas day like they do with the NBA.

I suppose we can't expect the next three weeks won't be much better, ratings-wise, either with the divisional championships and the Super Bowl.

Let's see if the Olympics can somehow jumpstart Americans into watching.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home